A Deskpad Labs study
How students use AI, and what school policies say about it
By Akshay Ganesh and Nathan Sun, seniors at Woodside Priory School. Presented to State Senator Josh Becker at the California Department of Education's AI working group, October 2026.
Our research reveals a major disconnect: none of the six enforceable Bay Area school AI policies we studied says what students may use AI for, and most center on whether AI wrote the work.
What we did
We randomly sampled 300 messages from Deskpad's data, and categorized each request into one of six categories by hand.
| Code | The student is asking the AI to… |
|---|---|
AUTHOR | write or rewrite text that would go into the assignment |
INFO | give facts, definitions, explanations, examples, or sources about the topic |
IDEATE | suggest ideas, claims, angles, a plan, or what to write next |
EVALUATE | judge the student's own work or reasoning |
EDIT | change specific wording in the student's own text |
TASK | explain the assignment, the prompt, or what the tool can see |
Here's what we found
87%
of student requests asked AI for something other than writing.
INFO, IDEATE, EVALUATE, EDIT, TASKAUTHOR 13%What students asked for
71%
of take-home requests were for ideas or feedback (IDEATE + EVALUATE)
53%
of in-class requests were for facts or answers (INFO)
What the six policies say
- Say what students may use AI for
- 0 of 6
- Center on whether AI wrote the work
- Most
- Say whether uses that leave no AI text behind are allowed
- None
What we propose
We propose that schools set AI rules by the role AI plays in a student's work, such as supplying facts, suggesting ideas, or giving feedback, and let teachers decide which roles are allowed on each assignment.
If you are writing an AI policy for a school or district, we would love to compare notes.
Get in touch